At least seven candidates who won on Nov. 3 are heading toward office with an open criminal matter or a criminal record. They range from a congresswoman under federal indictment to a state lawmaker arrested the day after his reelection.
Only one of them has a final criminal conviction on record. The other six are either awaiting court dates or have entered pleas tied to diversion programs. Under American law, those six are presumed innocent until a court finds otherwise.
All seven are Democrats. The Republicans with criminal cases that NexfinityNews identified on November ballots, including Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, all lost.
This piece goes through each case: what the record shows, what each candidate has said, and what the law allows to happen next.
Background
The 2026 midterms produced a broad Democratic wave. As of Nov. 5, Democrats held 54 Senate seats and 240 House seats, according to the Washington Examiner’s live tally.
Waves carry candidates into office in districts that neither party expected to be competitive. Those candidates often get less scrutiny from opponents, party committees and the press. The Washington Free Beacon noted that Axios previewed one such race two days before the election without mentioning the nominee’s pending felony charge.
In simple terms: when a party wins seats it didn’t expect to win, some of its winners were never fully vetted.
The Cases
| Winner | Office | Status | Type of case | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ericka Lomick | Texas House, District 93 | Convicted (federal, 2011) | Mortgage fraud, bank fraud, money laundering | Challenge before Texas Secretary of State; state canvass Nov. 17 |
| LaKesha Womack | U.S. House, NC-14 | Charged | State felony: failure to return rental car | Probable cause hearing Dec. 1 |
| LaMonica McIver | U.S. House, NJ-10 (reelected) | Indicted | Federal: assaulting/impeding officers | Back in district court after appeal |
| Carol Ammons | Illinois House, District 103 (reelected, unopposed) | Indicted | Federal: wire fraud, false statement, obstruction | Federal trial pending |
| Kelvin Lawrence | Alabama House, District 69 (reelected) | Guilty plea, pretrial diversion | State felony: forgery | Charge dropped if 300 community-service hours are completed |
| Anthony Ealy | Missouri House, District 36 (reelected) | Charged after the election | State misdemeanors: assault, peace disturbance | Cole County court |
| Anne Hughes | Connecticut House, District 135 (reelected) | Summons | State misdemeanor: larceny (campaign signs) | Court date next month |
The one conviction: Ericka Lomick (Texas House District 93)
Federal court records reviewed by the Dallas Express identify “Ericka L. Flood, a/k/a Ericka Lomick” as a defendant in a 2010 federal mortgage-fraud prosecution in North Carolina. A 2013 Fourth Circuit opinion shows she challenged her conviction from federal prison. The appeals court dismissed that challenge as untimely.
According to federal records cited by the Dallas Express and the Texas Tribune, she pleaded guilty in January 2011 to mortgage-fraud conspiracy, bank fraud and money-laundering conspiracy. She was sentenced to 63 months in prison, three years of supervised release and $300,000 in restitution. Earlier in the campaign, Lomick had told the Fort Worth Report she had never been convicted of a crime in any state.
She suspended her campaign in September. The deadline to remove her name had already passed, so she stayed on the ballot. She won about 51% of the vote against Republican Alan Blaylock, leading by 810 votes in unofficial returns, according to the Dallas Morning News, both in the regular election and in a special election to finish former Rep. Nate Schatzline’s term.
Texas Election Code §141.001 says a person “finally convicted of a felony” cannot be elected to public office unless pardoned or otherwise released from the resulting disabilities. Finishing a sentence does not restore eligibility on its own.
Lomick now says she can serve. In a Nov. 12 statement to the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, she confirmed her criminal history but said she had been “fully released from the resulting disabilities” of the conviction. She did not say by what mechanism.
On Nov. 13, Blaylock’s attorney, James E. “Trey” Trainor III of Dhillon Law Group, asked Secretary of State Robert Howden to declare Lomick ineligible and withhold her certificates of election for both terms. Trainor wrote that his team found no pardon and no order releasing her from the conviction’s disabilities. He asked for a response by noon Monday, Nov. 16; the state canvass deadline is Nov. 17. The Secretary of State’s office declined to comment Friday.
A 2019 Texas attorney general opinion treats restoring voting rights and restoring eligibility for office as separate questions. Completing a sentence does not, by itself, restore eligibility. As of publication, the document Lomick relies on has not been made public.
The seat carries more weight than usual. Republicans lost their Texas House majority on Nov. 3, according to the Tribune, leaving them in the minority for the first time since 2001.
In simple terms: Lomick says her rights were legally restored; her opponent says no record of that exists. The state has to decide quickly.
LaKesha Womack (U.S. House, NC-14)
Womack unseated Republican Rep. Tim Moore by just under three percentage points, according to the Washington Post.
She faces one count of felony failure to return a hired motor vehicle. The criminal summons alleges she rented a 2019 Toyota Corolla from Budget in Charlotte and did not return it by Oct. 23, 2019. The car’s stated value was $20,000. In North Carolina, the offense is a felony when the vehicle is worth more than $4,000.
The summons was issued in January 2020 but never served. A Polk County deputy served it on Oct. 11, 2026, three weeks before the election. Body camera footage obtained by WSOC-TV shows it was served outside a campaign stop.
Womack has acknowledged that she did not return the car on time. She said she was homeless then, had nowhere to receive mail, and did not know a case had been filed. She also questioned why the summons was served after six years, just weeks before the vote.
Her attorney, Harold Cogdell, said her first court appearance is now set for a Dec. 1 probable cause hearing. Former Mecklenburg County prosecutor Rob Heroy told reporters he expects the charge to be dismissed, calling such cases “notoriously throwaway charges.”
LaMonica McIver (U.S. House, NJ-10)
McIver won a second full term while under federal indictment. The charges stem from a May 2025 confrontation outside Delaney Hall, an immigration detention center in Newark. Prosecutors allege she struck and pushed federal officers during an arrest there. She has pleaded not guilty and has called the case political intimidation.
On Aug. 26, 2026, a divided Third Circuit panel ruled that the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause does not shield her from prosecution on two of the three counts. It sent the third count back to the trial judge. The panel also held that her vindictive-prosecution claim can be appealed only after trial. Judge Thomas Ambro dissented.
Two of the charges carry a maximum of eight years in prison. The case returns to U.S. District Judge Jamel Semper in Newark.
Carol Ammons (Illinois House, District 103)
Ammons, a Democrat from Urbana, was indicted in July on eight counts of wire fraud, one count of making a false statement, and two obstruction counts. Her husband, Champaign County Clerk Aaron Ammons, was indicted on obstruction-related charges in the same case.
Prosecutors allege Ammons helped organizations get state funding and then received cash kickbacks or payments to her daughter. Both Ammonses have pleaded not guilty and deny wrongdoing.
She ran unopposed, in an election administered by her husband’s office. Their lawyers asked to push the Nov. 17 trial date past the election. Separately, an Illinois House special investigating committee opened an inquiry in August.
Kelvin Lawrence (Alabama House, District 69)
The day after he was reelected, Lawrence, a Democrat from Hayneville, pleaded guilty to a Class C felony forgery charge. It stems from a 2024 case alleging he altered a builder’s license.
A 12-month sentence was suspended, and he entered a pretrial diversion program. If he completes 300 hours of community service, the charge will be dropped. Lawrence did not respond to requests for comment from the Montgomery Advertiser.
In simple terms: he admitted the charge in court, but if he meets the program’s terms, it will not stay on his record as a conviction.
Anthony Ealy (Missouri House, District 36)
Ealy, a Democrat from Grandview, was arrested in Jefferson City on Nov. 4, the day after winning reelection. He was charged the next day with fourth-degree assault and peace disturbance. Both are misdemeanors.
A probable cause statement alleges that Ealy mentioned having a firearm and repeatedly threatened to kill a man outside a business where a family was arranging a funeral. According to KCTV, Ealy denied making threats or mentioning a firearm after being read his rights.
Anne Hughes (Connecticut House, District 135)
Hughes, a Democrat from Easton, faces a misdemeanor larceny summons. Her Republican opponent, Darrell Harris, had put an AirTag in one of his campaign signs, and police tracked it to her home on Oct. 30.
On body camera video, Hughes told investigators she had picked up signs from the road and put them in recycling. She has said she will let the court process proceed and plans to serve her term.
What the Law Allows
The rules depend on the office.
Congress. The Constitution sets only three requirements for House members: age, citizenship and state residency. The Supreme Court held in Powell v. McCormack (1969) that the House cannot add to those requirements when deciding whether to seat a member-elect. A pending charge, or even a conviction, does not stop Womack or McIver from being sworn in.
After that, the House has two tools. It can expel a member by a two-thirds vote. And under House Rule XXIII, a member convicted of a crime that carries a possible sentence of two years or more should not vote on the floor or in committee until they are cleared or reelected. Womack’s charge is a Class H felony. Depending on prior record, its sentencing range can exceed two years.
State legislatures. Each state sets its own qualifications. Texas is the strictest of the states in this group: a final felony conviction makes a person ineligible unless they have been pardoned or released from that disability. Most states, including Illinois, Missouri, Connecticut and Alabama, leave discipline of sitting members to the chamber itself, through investigating committees, censure or expulsion.
In simple terms: the voters decide who wins, but it is the chamber, and in Texas the eligibility law, that decides who stays.
Impact
The practical effect varies by case.
- Lomick may never take her seat. Her opponent’s challenge is now before the Secretary of State. If she is ruled ineligible, HD 93 would have to be filled another way; state officials have not said how.
- Womack and McIver will almost certainly be sworn in Jan. 3. Their cases will play out while they serve, and a conviction would trigger House Rule XXIII.
- Ammons faces federal trial and a House inquiry at the same time.
- Lawrence, Ealy and Hughes face cases that, as charged, would not by themselves disqualify them from office.
For voters in these districts, the result may be representation that is partly occupied by litigation: court dates, possible committee removals, and the chance of a special election.
Analysis
Two patterns stand out.
First, vetting failed in different ways. Lomick’s record was not public until after Texas’s withdrawal deadline. Womack’s summons sat unserved for six years. Ammons had no opponent at all. In each case, the normal checks of primaries, opposition research and press coverage either didn’t apply or came too late.
Second, the timing of several cases is disputed. Womack questions why a six-year-old summons was served three weeks before Election Day. McIver argues her prosecution is vindictive, a claim the Third Circuit said must wait until after trial. A court has not yet ruled on whether either complaint has merit.
The partisan split also needs context. Every winner on this list is a Democrat, but the Republicans with criminal cases that NexfinityNews identified all lost:
- Ken Paxton, whose securities fraud case ended in a 2024 pretrial agreement without a plea, lost the Texas Senate race to James Talarico.
- Aaron Spencer, the Arkansas sheriff’s nominee whose murder charge was dismissed with prejudice after evidence was mishandled, lost to independent Larry Behnke.
- Vermont state Sen. Terry Williams, who pleaded not guilty to a misdemeanor domestic assault charge, lost his reelection bid.
That means the one-sided list may say more about which way the wave broke than about either party’s tolerance for candidates with legal trouble. In 2018, the reverse happened: Republican Reps. Chris Collins and Duncan Hunter won reelection while under federal indictment.
Party Over Person: Why Voters Do It
Many voters knew about these cases and backed the candidate anyway. Political scientists have a name for the reason: negative partisanship, which means voting mainly to keep the other party out of power.
The trend has grown sharply. In 1978, only 9% of Democrats and 7% of Republicans held a very negative view of the other party. By 2024, 64% in each party did, according to Boise State political scientist Charlie Hunt. On a 0-to-100 “feeling thermometer,” average sentiment toward the other party has fallen to 19.
The case voters make for it. A legislator votes with their caucus on most bills, and control of the chamber sets the agenda. Research also finds voters can separate character from policy. They may rate a scandal-plagued candidate low on morality but still prefer them on party and shared views, according to a study in Political Behavior.
The case against it. Critics argue it lets parties skip vetting, because the other side will always look worse. A member who is convicted or ruled ineligible can also cost the party the seat anyway, through House Rule XXIII or a vacancy. And research Hunt cites finds that scandals in a voter’s own party can make them more loyal to it, not less.
The 2026 results suggest the effect is strongest down-ballot. Paxton’s record was covered heavily for years, and he lost a statewide race. Womack’s charge drew less attention, and she won a district that Moore carried by 17 points in 2024.
In simple terms: many voters are choosing a team, not a person.
Conclusion
One convicted felon, three people under felony charges, one felony plea in diversion, and two misdemeanor cases. That is the accurate count, and the distinctions matter.
Lomick’s case is about eligibility, and Texas law may settle it. The rest will be settled in court, where every defendant is presumed innocent until proven guilty.
The bigger question is how voters keep ending up with these choices. When primaries go uncontested, records surface after the deadlines, and a wave sweeps in nominees nobody vetted, the ballot becomes the first background check. And it is a poor one.
Key Takeaways
- At least seven Nov. 3 winners have open criminal cases or records. Only one, Ericka Lomick (TX HD 93), has a final conviction.
- Texas law bars people finally convicted of a felony from office unless pardoned or released from that disability. Lomick says her rights were restored; her opponent has asked the Secretary of State to rule her ineligible.
- Members of Congress cannot be blocked from their seats over charges (Powell v. McCormack). House Rule XXIII restricts voting only after a qualifying conviction.
- McIver’s prosecution survived a Third Circuit appeal on two of three counts. Womack’s probable cause hearing is Dec. 1.
- Every winner on the list is a Democrat. The Republicans with criminal cases identified on November ballots, including Paxton, lost.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can someone under criminal indictment be sworn into Congress? Yes. The Constitution sets only age, citizenship and residency requirements, and Powell v. McCormack (1969) bars the House from adding more. The House can expel a member by a two-thirds vote.
Can a convicted felon serve in the Texas Legislature? Not unless pardoned or released from the conviction’s resulting disabilities, under Texas Election Code §141.001. Finishing a sentence does not restore eligibility on its own.
What happens if a member of Congress is convicted? Under House Rule XXIII, a member convicted of a crime punishable by two or more years in prison should not vote until cleared or reelected.
Do political parties run background checks on candidates? No law requires it, and most states rely on candidates’ own sworn statements. Delaware requires criminal history checks for state and county offices, but not for federal office.
Sources
- Washington Examiner: 2026 midterm live updates
- Texas Tribune: GOP candidate seeks to block Dem’s win amid eligibility question
- Dallas Express via Yahoo: Texas Democrat’s House win faces felony challenge
- Dallas Express: PAC targets HD 93 candidate Ericka Lomick over federal criminal record
- Dallas Morning News: Lomick leads Texas House race amid eligibility question
- IBTimes: Lomick wins Texas District 93
- Texas Election Code §141.001
- Womack criminal summons, File No. 20CR201748-590 (via Washington Free Beacon)
- Washington Free Beacon: Womack heads to court
- WSOC-TV: Candidate calls felony warrant a distraction
- WBTV: Felony warrant served to NC-14 candidate
- Washington Post via DNYUZ: Womack faces a felony charge
- Third Circuit opinion, United States v. McIver, Nos. 25-3573 & 26-1122
- Roll Call: McIver not immune from prosecution
- Capitol News Illinois: Ammons indicted
- Chicago Sun-Times: Ammons indicted
- Capitol Fax: Ammons ask for trial delay
- Montgomery Advertiser via Yahoo: Alabama lawmaker pleads guilty
- KSHB: Rep. Anthony Ealy charged
- KCTV: Ealy arrested
- Local 12: Reelected lawmaker arrested over campaign signs
- KATV: Behnke beats Spencer
- VTDigger: Sen. Terry Williams loses reelection
- KTVU: Talarico defeats Paxton
- Powell v. McCormack, 395 U.S. 486 (1969)
- The Conversation (Charlie Hunt) via Cobb County Courier: Americans keep voting for scandal-prone candidates
- Political Behavior: Scandal, partisanship and voter evaluations
- Delaware Department of Elections: Getting on the Ballot





