New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, that the NYPD will disband its Strategic Response Group (SRG), the unit that has handled both counterterrorism and large-scale protest response since 2015.
The unit’s roughly 500 officers will be reassigned, and the SRG is scheduled to be dissolved in spring 2027, according to ABC7 New York’s joint interview with the mayor and commissioner.
The announcement fulfills one of Mamdani’s most specific campaign promises. It also leaves open the question critics on both sides are already asking: how much will actually change on the street?
Background
Then-Commissioner Bill Bratton created the SRG in 2015 to consolidate eight borough task forces into a single unit that could respond to terror threats and large emergencies, City & State reported.
The unit soon took on protest duty. Its handling of the 2020 George Floyd demonstrations, where marchers were met with bicycles, shields and batons, made it the focus of a long civil-liberties campaign. The NYCLU and more than 50 organizations launched a campaign to disband the unit in 2021. The NYCLU has said its database recorded 455 complaints against SRG officers from 2015 to 2021.
The resulting class action, Payne v. City of New York, ended in a 2023 settlement that barred kettling and imposed a tiered system limiting when SRG officers can be deployed. The lowest tiers bar SRG deployment entirely.
Mamdani pledged to disband the unit as a candidate in December 2024. Tisch, retained from the Adams administration, resisted. At a March 2026 budget hearing she said her talks with the mayor were about “the future of how we police protests generally,” not disbandment, and that the SRG was present at 245 of the 4,255 protests the NYPD facilitated in 2025, about 6%. In April, Mamdani told The New York Times he held final authority over the department and would overrule the commissioner if necessary.
The deadlock broke last week, when Politico reported a plan was imminent. Monday’s announcement came with Tisch at the mayor’s side.
What the Plan Does
The SRG’s duties are being split among four units, according to amNY and Fox News:
- Counterterrorism moves to the NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau, including heavy-weapons deployments at critical infrastructure.
- Crowd management and arrests move to a new Patrol Support Division in the Patrol Services Bureau. Its officers get crowd-management training but will spend most of their time on routine patrol, missing-person searches, major events like the Marathon, and severe-weather traffic.
- A new 30-officer First Amendment Support Team (FAST) in the Community Affairs Bureau will lead dialogue with protest organizers at first.
- A civilian Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division inside the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety will take the lead role when it launches in 2028, starting with about 30 staff. Its staff will carry no weapons and have no arrest powers.
In simple terms: civilians and specially trained officers will talk to protest organizers before and during a demonstration, and a separate group of police officers will stand by to make arrests if needed.
The plan also restricts tactics. Kettling, tear gas and long guns are banned. Pepper spray may no longer be used as a general crowd-control tool, long-range acoustic devices are capped at 90 decibels, and bicycles may not be used as weapons except to prevent death or serious injury.
City Hall says the reorganization will not change NYPD headcount or add cost.
The Model Behind It
The dialogue approach is drawn from Columbus, Ohio, where City Hall and NYPD officials traveled in April to study a police “dialogue unit.” Versions of it have also been used in London and Portland, Oregon.
Clifford Stott, a crowd-behavior scholar who helped develop the Columbus model, told Gothamist the change is “a very positive move.” He cited better early information and more trust between police and protesters. He also flagged a risk: this is the first time the NYPD will rely on civilians to talk with protesters, which could cause problems when counter-protesters are present.
New York would be the largest U.S. city to try the approach.
The Study Behind the Model: Who Wrote It, Who Paid
The main evidence for the Columbus approach was written largely by the people who built it. Three of its five authors are Columbus police officers who run the program being evaluated.
The paper is “The Columbus Model: Crowd Psychology, Dialogue Policing and Protest Management in the U.S.A.”, published July 17, 2025, in the peer-reviewed journal Policing and Society (DOI 10.1080/10439463.2025.2532546). It describes itself as the first systematic empirical analysis of a dialogue-led protest policing model in a U.S. department.
| Author | Position | Role in the Columbus program |
|---|---|---|
| Clifford Stott | Professor, Keele University (UK); visiting faculty, Ohio State’s John Glenn College | Consultant who trained Columbus officers and helped design the model |
| Shahidul “Russell” Hassan | Wolf Chair in Public and International Affairs, Glenn College | Adviser to the city’s 2020 after-action review; observes protests with Stott |
| Duane Mabry | Commander, Columbus Division of Police | Built the dialogue team |
| Steve Dyer | Sergeant, Columbus Division of Police | Dialogue team leader; co-wrote its training |
| Kolin Straub | Columbus Division of Police (lieutenant as of 2026) | Dialogue team officer and trainer |
Sources for roles: Ohio State Glenn College, The Lantern, Columbus Dispatch via Yahoo, Police1.
How it was funded. The public repository copy of the paper carries no funding or conflict-of-interest statement; the journal version needs checking. The program it studies was paid for publicly, through several channels:
- City of Columbus and Ohio State. Glenn College says the reform effort received support and financial assistance from Ohio State and the City of Columbus.
- U.S. Department of Justice. The same page credits a grant from the DOJ’s Community Oriented Policing Services (COPS) program. No amount is given.
- A city contract with Stott’s firm. In July 2023, Columbus City Council considered a $94,000 contract with Conflict Management Ltd., which WOSU identified as Stott’s firm, to work with the dialogue unit.
- The 2020 after-action review. The city’s independent review of its 2020 protest response, led by former U.S. Attorney Carter Stewart with Glenn College, was budgeted at about $250,000, primarily from Columbus police funds.
- Spreading the model. Stott is lead author of the May 2026 Portland Framework, national dialogue-policing guidance written with officers from eight departments. It was produced under a DOJ COPS grant to the Portland Police Bureau.
What the method can and can’t show. The study used participatory action research. In simple terms, the researchers watched police handle protests, advised changes, then judged whether the changes worked. It covered more than 60 protest events.
The authors report that the approach helped contain conflict and “marginalise confrontational actors,” and that crowds often policed themselves. They also report resistance to the change inside both the police and protest communities.
Action research is an established method, and the paper passed peer review. But it is not an independent evaluation: the consultant who designed the model and the officers who run it assessed their own work. The abstract describes no comparison group of departments policing protests the traditional way. NexfinityNews found no independent outcome study of the Columbus model.
None of this shows the findings are wrong. It means the strongest claim available is that the model’s designers report it works, not that outside researchers have confirmed it.
The Untested Case: Organized Confrontation
The plan does not assume every protest is peaceful. It keeps police who make arrests, moved to the Patrol Support Division. The open question is how the dialogue approach performs when an organized group wants confrontation and will not talk.
Dialogue policing depends on a counterpart. Its theory holds that heavy-handed tactics unite a crowd against police, while trust lets officers isolate a violent few. That works only if organizers engage. A group that refuses leaves the city with its arrest unit and little else.
New York’s protest landscape includes well-resourced organizing networks. The most-reported is the network funded by tech entrepreneur Neville Roy Singham. The People’s Forum, a Midtown activist hub, received $22.4 million from Singham, according to tax filings cited by Fox News. Federal prosecutors are examining the network’s funding. Singham and the groups he funds have not been charged with any crime.
The NYPD has also blamed outsiders for specific clashes. After a 2024 Bay Ridge protest, police said 36 of the 41 people arrested were not from the neighborhood or the city, and a third had prior arrests at violent protests.
Funding is not the same as violence. Unions, churches and advocacy groups across the political spectrum pay staff and buy signs, and the First Amendment treats them alike. The relevant question is narrower: can professional organizers plan around a civilian dialogue team, or simply decline to engage?
The model’s own designer flagged a related weakness. Clifford Stott told Gothamist that relying on civilians is new for the NYPD and could cause problems when counter-protesters are present.
The arrest capacity is the backstop, and it is changing too. SRG officers specialized in crowds full-time. Patrol Support Division officers will spend most of their time on routine patrol and major events. The PBA argues that shift threatens public and officer safety.
Asked at a Nov. 17 briefing what happens when a march escalates, Mamdani said civilians would not be “on the front lines” once a march turns, and that police would be present for any violence. He did not describe how the handoff from civilians to police would work.
Questions NexfinityNews put to City Hall and the NYPD that remain unanswered:
- What is the protocol when organizers refuse contact with the dialogue division?
- How many Patrol Support Division officers will be available citywide for a large, unpermitted demonstration?
- Has the city contracted Clifford Stott or Ohio State, and on what terms?
- Will the city commission an independent evaluation of the new model?
Why Not Reform the SRG Instead?
The city could have added a dialogue team without disbanding the SRG. Columbus, the model New York says it is following, did exactly that.
Columbus did not eliminate its tactical units. Its model, as described in the Policing and Society study, uses “graded tactical deployment”: a dialogue team works out front, with tactical officers held in reserve. The dialogue layer was added on top of existing capacity.
The administration’s case for disbanding. City Hall offers three reasons a dialogue team alone would not be enough:
- Separation of missions. The SRG’s officers handled both counterterrorism and protests. Keeping the unit would leave the counterterrorism unit as the backup behind every dialogue team. Mamdani said protesters “should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat.”
- The unit’s record. Critics argue a culture tied to 455 complaints from 2015 to 2021, by the NYCLU’s count, could not be fixed by adding a team beside it. Officers for the new Patrol Support Division will be vetted against CCRB and Internal Affairs complaints.
- The campaign promise. Mamdani pledged to disband the unit, not reform it.
The case that disbanding was unnecessary. NYPD officials have said the department already had a version of the talking layer: Community Affairs protest liaisons who work with organizers before and during demonstrations. Tisch herself argued for reform, not elimination, as recently as March.
And the capacity is not disappearing. Tisch told ABC7 that many SRG officers will move to the Counterterrorism Bureau, and that New Yorkers will see “the very same response” in crowd-control situations.
What disbanding changes that reform would not. Compared with keeping the SRG and adding FAST, the practical differences come down to three:
- Crowd-control officers become generalists. Patrol Support Division officers will spend most of their time on patrol and major events, not full-time crowd work.
- Officers are re-vetted against their complaint histories before reassignment.
- Protest response is cut off from counterterrorism weapons and staffing.
The tactical bans on kettling, tear gas and long guns could have been imposed on the SRG as it stood. The separation of missions and the re-vetting are harder to achieve inside an existing unit.
In simple terms: the city traded full-time specialists for a cleaner separation between protest policing and counterterrorism. Whether that trade improves outcomes is what the 2027 rollout will test.
Reaction
Council Member Lincoln Restler said the plan follows best practices from cities like Columbus. The Legal Aid Society praised the changes but called for “vigilant oversight.” The Justice Committee was cautiously positive but warned the change could amount to a rebranding of the SRG.
The Police Benevolent Association opposes the plan, arguing it threatens public and officer safety. Ahead of the announcement, PBA President Patrick Hendry said Mamdani had spent years “demonizing one particular group of police officers.”
Tisch framed her support as conditional on security. “I would never support changes that diminish the NYPD’s ability to protect New Yorkers,” she said in a statement, adding that the changes “will make us a stronger, more effective department.”
The Mayor’s Response
Asked for comment, the Mayor’s office sent NexfinityNews remarks Mamdani made at a press availability on Nov. 17, the day after the announcement. The remarks did not directly answer NexfinityNews’ written questions on staffing levels, vetting criteria or outside contracts.
On whether the plan goes far enough, Mamdani repeated that counterterrorism and protest response are “fundamentally different responsibilities” and said the city is “fundamentally transforming” how it prepares for and responds to protests.
Timeline. Mamdani said the plan takes effect in 90 days, beginning with the First Amendment Support Team. The civilian division, housed in the Office of Community Safety, will launch in 2028 with a starting staff of about 30. He said hiring details will be released closer to launch. A reporter’s question about background checks for civilian staff was not answered in the remarks provided.
FAST stays. Once the civilian division is running, FAST will be scaled back but not dissolved, keeping a liaison role.
Civilians and escalation. Asked what happens when a march turns confrontational, Mamdani said the civilian role is concentrated before and early in a protest. If a march is “transforming into something else,” he said, “it’s not for civilians to be on the front lines of that.” Police, he said, “will always be present in the case of any kind of violence.”
Patrol Support Division eligibility. Asked whether current SRG officers can join, Mamdani said every applicant must meet a “high level of eligibility” regardless of where in the department they come from. He did not say what the threshold is.
Bicycles. Officers may still use bicycles for transportation. The restriction applies to using them as a weapon or for aggression.
The CURB Act. Mamdani said he supports the bill and that it would “codify” the new approach for future administrations. A reporter cited Council Member Oswald Feliz’s reading that the bill as written would bar the new specialized units from responding to protests. Mamdani said the new units are not “in tension” with the bill and that such questions belong in the legislative process.
The commissioner. Asked where he and Tisch compromised, Mamdani did not name a specific point. He described 11 months of talks, including a staff trip to Columbus, and said the plan is “something that we both stand behind.”
Analysis: Two Descriptions of the Same Plan
The mayor and the commissioner described Monday’s announcement in noticeably different terms.
Mamdani called it “a completely new approach to how we treat protest in our city.” Tisch, in the same ABC7 interview, said “nothing would change about the way that the NYPD responds to crowd control conditions,” and that New Yorkers can expect “the very same response that they are accustomed to.”
Both statements can be accurate. The SRG name and its dual counterterrorism-protest mandate end. But the arrest capacity at demonstrations does not disappear; it moves to the Patrol Support Division. Whether that is structural reform or a reorganization depends on details the city has not yet released:
- Size. No staffing figure has been given for the Patrol Support Division.
- Vetting. Officer selection will consider CCRB and Internal Affairs complaints, but the administration has not said which findings would disqualify an officer.
- Timetable. The Mayor said the plan takes effect in 90 days and the civilian division launches in 2028. ABC7 reported the SRG will be dissolved in spring 2027. No firm dates have been published.
- Durability. The plan rests on mayoral authority. The Council’s CURB Act, which would bar the NYPD from recreating a similar unit under another name, has 25 sponsors plus Public Advocate Jumaane Williams but remains stalled in the Public Safety Committee. Mamdani says he supports it as a way to codify the change.
Several of the tactical limits also build on the 2023 Payne settlement, which already barred kettling. The new plan extends those limits, but part of the list codifies obligations the city already had.
The 6% figure cuts both ways. Supporters of the SRG say it shows the unit was reserved for demonstrations involving criminal activity. Critics say the unit’s reputation was shaped by those high-profile deployments regardless of frequency.
Conclusion
Mamdani has delivered the headline promise: the Strategic Response Group will cease to exist. The tests come in stages: the Patrol Support Division’s first large, contentious demonstration after the plan takes effect in early 2027, and the civilian division’s launch in 2028.
Until the city publishes headcount, vetting standards and dates, the public has two official descriptions of the same plan, and no data yet to decide between them.
NexfinityNews sent requests for comment on Nov. 17 to the Mayor’s Office, the NYPD, the NYCLU, Council Member Chi Ossé and Clifford Stott. The Mayor’s office responded with the Mayor’s Nov. 17 press remarks, summarized above. Responses from the other recipients will be added if received.
Key Takeaways
- The NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (about 500 officers) will be dissolved by spring 2027, Mamdani and Tisch announced Nov. 16, 2026.
- Counterterrorism moves to the Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau; protest arrests move to a new Patrol Support Division.
- A civilian, unarmed Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division will lead protest engagement starting in 2028, modeled on Columbus, Ohio; FAST will be scaled back but keep a liaison role.
- Kettling, tear gas and long guns are banned; pepper spray and acoustic devices are restricted.
- Key details remain undisclosed: Patrol Support Division size, disqualifying vetting criteria, firm dates, and whether the Council will codify the change.
- The Columbus study behind the model was co-written by the consultant who designed it and three officers who run it; no independent outcome study was found.
- Columbus added its dialogue team on top of existing tactical units rather than disbanding them; NYC chose disbandment to separate protest response from counterterrorism and re-vet officers.
Hero image: AI-generated editorial illustration.





